Pinsent Masons Behavioural Interview: Competencies & STAR
What a behavioural interview at a commercial law firm is really testing, the competencies you should prepare for, and how to build STAR answers that sound specific and credible.
What a behavioural interview at a law firm is really testing
Behavioural (or competency-based) interviews rest on a simple idea: how you have acted in the past is a useful guide to how you will act in future. Instead of asking what you would do in theory, the interviewer asks for a real example: "Tell me about a time you worked under pressure" or "Describe a situation where you had to persuade someone."
Large commercial firms such as Pinsent Masons commonly use this format, alongside application forms, assessments and sometimes a one-way video interview, because it lets them compare candidates against the same criteria. We don't have, and won't pretend to have, inside knowledge of their exact current questions or scoring. What we can do is explain how competency interviews at firms of this type generally work, so you can prepare properly.
Always check the firm's current careers pages and your invitation email for the specific stages, format and any stated values. That is the most reliable source, and it is far better than interview forums.
Competencies commonly assessed at commercial law firms
Wording differs between firms, but the themes below appear again and again in legal recruitment. Use them as a preparation framework, then map them to the language on the firm's own graduate or lateral hiring pages.
- Teamwork and collaboration: contributing to a group, handling disagreement, supporting others.
- Client focus and commercial awareness: understanding what a client or stakeholder actually needs, and how decisions affect a business.
- Communication and influencing: explaining complex information clearly and adapting your style to the audience.
- Resilience and adaptability: responding to setbacks, feedback or changing priorities.
- Drive and initiative: taking ownership without being asked and following through.
- Attention to detail and quality: spotting errors, checking your work, managing risk.
- Integrity and professionalism: acting honestly and sensibly when under pressure or when a situation is grey.
Do your research on the firm's own language
Read the firm's values, graduate or recruitment pages and any published guidance on the selection process. Note recurring words (collaboration, innovation, client service and so on) and notice which of your experiences naturally demonstrate them.
This is not about parroting buzzwords. It is about choosing examples that are relevant. If the firm emphasises working in teams across offices or disciplines, a story about coordinating with people who had different priorities will land better than one about working alone.
Reading about it isn't the same as doing it on camera.
Run a free timed mock interview →Structure every answer with STAR
STAR keeps your answer focused and makes it easy for an interviewer to score. Spend roughly 10-15% on Situation and Task combined, around 60% on Action and the remainder on Result.
The key discipline is to say "I", not just "we". Interviewers are assessing your contribution, not your team's.
- Situation: the context in one or two sentences. Where, when, what was at stake?
- Task: your specific responsibility or goal.
- Action: the steps you personally took and why you chose them. This is the heart of the answer.
- Result: the outcome, ideally measurable, plus what you learned or would do differently.
Worked example: "Tell me about a time you handled competing priorities"
This is an illustrative answer, not a model to memorise. Your own example will be stronger because it is true and specific.
"In my final year I was treasurer of a student society while also finishing my dissertation (Situation). Two weeks before my submission deadline, our biggest annual event needed its budget finalised and sponsors confirmed, so I had to make sure neither task slipped (Task). I listed every outstanding job, estimated the time each needed and identified the sponsor follow-ups as the only items with an external deadline. I blocked out two evenings to complete those, asked the committee's secretary to take over the room bookings, and agreed with my supervisor a firm schedule of dissertation milestones so that I wasn't relying on last-minute effort (Action). We confirmed all three sponsors a week early, the event came in within budget, and I submitted my dissertation on time. I learned to delegate earlier and to be explicit about trade-offs, and I now do that at the start of any busy period (Result)."
Notice what makes it work: a clear prioritisation logic, a personal decision to delegate, a concrete outcome and a brief reflection. It runs to around 150-180 words, which is roughly 70-90 seconds spoken.
Common mistakes and how to avoid them
Most weak answers fail in predictable ways. Check yours against these contrasts.
- Don't spend half your time on background. Do get to your actions within 20-30 seconds.
- Don't say "we did" throughout. Do make your own decisions and reasoning explicit.
- Don't choose a story where nothing went wrong. Do pick one with a real challenge and show how you handled it.
- Don't invent or inflate results. Do be honest; interviewers probe, and credibility matters in a profession built on trust.
- Don't recycle one example for every question. Do prepare four to six varied stories that can flex across competencies.
- Don't skip the reflection. Do end with what you learned or would change.
A practical preparation plan
Build a story bank first: write down six experiences from work, study, volunteering or sport, and tag each with the competencies it could evidence. Then draft each in STAR bullet points rather than full scripts, so you sound natural rather than rehearsed.
Next, practise out loud and against the clock. If your process includes a one-way video interview, where you see a question, get a short preparation window and record a time-limited answer, it feels very different from writing notes. A tool such as ScreenReady lets you rehearse that format on camera and get feedback on structure and clarity, though a friend or careers adviser timing you is also valuable.
Finally, review your recordings for filler words, pace and whether your Action section is doing most of the work. Two or three rounds of this usually produces a noticeable improvement.
Frequently asked questions
What competencies does Pinsent Masons assess?
The firm sets its own criteria, and these can change, so check its current careers pages and your invitation. Commercial law firms generally assess themes such as teamwork, client focus, commercial awareness, communication, resilience, drive and attention to detail, so preparing examples for each is a sensible approach.
How long should a behavioural answer be?
Aim for roughly 90 seconds to two minutes unless the interviewer or video platform sets a different limit. That is long enough to cover all four STAR stages with detail, but short enough to stay focused. Practise with a timer so it becomes instinctive.
Can I use examples from university or part-time jobs?
Yes. Interviewers care about the behaviour you demonstrate, not the setting. A society role, a retail job, a group project or volunteering can all work, provided the situation had real stakes and your personal actions are clear.
What if I can't think of an example during the interview?
Take a brief pause to think; a few seconds of silence is fine. If nothing fits perfectly, choose the closest relevant story and focus on the competency being asked about. Having a prepared story bank makes this far less likely to happen.
Practise for these companies
Put this into practice
ScreenReady builds a realistic, timed mock interview around your target role, records your answers on camera, and gives AI feedback on structure, evidence and delivery.
Start a free mock interview →